Thanks for helping us search for America’s Favorite Grilled Cheese. Voting is now closed as we tally the results.
Check back on April 7th for America’s Choice on Instagram and BordenCheese.com.
Bread. Spread. Fillings. Everyone has an opinion. But at Borden®, we know it’s the cheese that makes the sandwich.
Which grilled cheese will win America’s Choice?
The ooey-gooey timeless gold-standard grilled cheese sandwich featuring Borden American and Borden Extra Sharp Melts on buttery white bread.
Inspired by 2026’s hottest food trend, this sandwich pairs Borden American Singles and Borden Provolone with spicy dill pickles, whipped cream cheese, and ranch seasoning.
A savory sensation built with Borden Swiss Slices, crispy fried onion strings, and a tangy BBQ sauce kick.
A culinary marvel where classic bread is swapped for cheesy waffles, layered with melty Borden American Cheese, Mild Cheddar Slices, Mozzarella, Sharp Cheddar, and Aged Parmesan.